Washington Legal Defense
Free Consultation
The Garrity Guarantee Get 150+ Years of Combined Litigation Experience on Your Side
Hester Law Group

The Garrity Guarantee

Many years ago the United States Supreme Court, in Garrity v. State of New Jersey, 385 U.S. 493, 87 S.Ct. 616 (1967), held the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits use in subsequent criminal proceedings of confessions obtained under threat of removal from office. The protection extends to all, whether they are policemen or other members of body politic.

Justice Douglas delivered an opinion in that case that involved the investigation by the state of police officers who allegedly were fixing traffic tickets. There was a statute in existence that essentially said that if you refused to answer questions that relate to any investigation conducted by the state, criminal or otherwise, you could be removed from office or lose your position. The particular officers, after being advised of the existence of this rule, responded to questions. Their answers were used as evidence against them in a criminal case wherein they were convicted of conspiracy to obstruct justice.

Their conviction was reversed by the Supreme Court, which noted that the defendants, by virtue of the circumstances under which their confessions were made, found themselves “between the rock and the whirlpool.”

The case is interesting in that it post-dates Miranda. Miranda is referenced by the Court, giving some additional insight and understanding of the concept behind Miranda and the protections offered by the Constitution as it relates to incriminating statements. The reference to Miranda was a reminder of the Supreme Court’s ruling that if the conduct of the government is likely to exert such pressure upon an individual as to disable him or her from making a free and rational choice, then any statements that are made under those circumstances would not be voluntary.

The Court further indicated that the real question is whether a state, contrary to the requirement of the Fourteenth Amendment, can use the threat of discharge to secure incriminatory evidence against an employee. The Court concluded that “policemen, like teachers and lawyers, are not relegated to a water-downed version of constitutional rights.”

This case, I think, is important to practitioners and should be used in arguments dealing with questions of whether or not a defendant’s statement has been taken in violation of Miranda, even with a waiver. The Court acknowledged that the coercion that vitiates a confession can be mental, as well as physical and that the blood of the accused is not the only hallmark of an unconstitutional inquisition.

Obviously, when you hear from your client the words, “I gave a statement because the police said if I cooperated they wouldn’t keep me in jail and I would be able to go home to my family,” or, “if you cooperate with us, you’re going to get the benefit of our cooperation,” or, “if you don’t cooperate, the judge is going to look unkindly upon you and send you to jail for a longer time,” then you’re looking at conduct that is coercive. Even if they have signed a waiver of their Miranda rights, one should seriously take on the challenge of having the statements declared to be a product of coercive conduct as defined in Garrity and Miranda.

Categories
  • Washington Association for Justice
  • The National Trial Lawyers Top 100
  • Tacoma-Pierce County Bar Association
  • American Board of Trial Advocates
  • American Association for Justice
  • Washington State Bar Association
  • Avvo 10.0 Rating

Success Stories

  • If he said he was going to do something he did it. He has integrity.

    “Wayne Fricke is a terrific lawyer who knows the law. The following are only several of many ways Mr. Fricke supported me during my time of crisis: 1. Explained the charges against me in a manner that ...”

    - Former Client
  • He always exceeds expectations.

    “Mr. Fricke has been our family lawyer for about 5 years. He has done an amazing job representing my family and I. He always exceeds expectations and informs us on everything going on.”

    - Jen
  • He, at no time, treated me as though I was guilty.

    “I was accused of domestic violence and need a Lawyer to defend me. Not knowing who to hire I started with Mr. K.W. This lawyer did not seem to believe in my innocence and I was looking at 3 to 5 ...”

    - Craig
  • Mr. Fricke had his office call me weekly for updates.

    “A few years ago, I was involved in a car accident. Due to my injuries, I hired an attorney who seemingly disappeared. I was in crisis after calling the court and finding out my case had been dismissed ...”

    - Sharyl
  • He is always honest and straight forward.

    “I hired Lance Hester to help me with 2 different legal matters. One was a felony criminal case and the other was a family law issue. In the felony criminal case this individual had everything to lose ...”

    - Former Client
/

Proven Results

  • Reduced Sentence Drug Crime
  • Case Dismissed Domestic Violence
  • Four Felony Charges Dismissed Four Felony Counts
  • Reduced Sentence Drug Distribution
  • Vacated Conviction 4th Degree Assault
  • Case Dismissed Possession of Stolen Property
  • Two Restraining Orders Granted Anti-harassment Orders
  • Federal Court Success Federal Probation Violation
  • Case Dismissed Rape
  • Life Sentence Avoided Federal Criminal Sex Charges
/

Why Choose the Hester Law Group?

  • Accessible to Clients

    We understand the urgency clients have when they need an attorney. We are availableĀ  24/7 to help you.

  • We Truly Care

    We feel honored to help someone through the toughest time they will ever go through.

  • Personalized Approach

    At Hester Law Group, we use a personal approach that best suits the needs of our clients.

  • Unparalleled Experience

    We have been a successful team for two decades and have over 130 years of combined experience.

We're Available 24/7

Get Started on Your Defense Today
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.